Wednesday, 13 May 2015

Rahman's Sunshine Orchestra


Rahman's Sunshine Orchestra

AR RAHMAN



The Sunshine Orchestra creates music and jobs, one of the biggest challenges: AR Rahman

How did the idea to start the Sunshine Orchestra come up?

I think it’s a 40’s syndrome, where you feel you are going to die and before that you have to do something good (laughs). I had heard rumours about so many people starting a school but nothing really happened. Our session orchestra has really been amazing, but I never saw anybody who wanted their sons or daughters to become musicians. The children all became doctors or engineers… so they worked very hard to ensure that their kids didn’t take up music which I thought was a good thing but not good for music. 


When I started the KM Conservatory (his music school) most of the kids came in for piano or composition or voice courses. Not many people took up strings because it is a hard instrument and it needs commitment. And the decision of staying loyal to the art of strings playing - I never trusted that a kid from an upper middle class family would be in it. That’s when I thought like ‘what am I doing, we have a wealth of music’. People are people and in the eyes of God everybody is equal. We say that but we never see people believing in it. At that point of time, I really felt that this is the universal truth.

How was the initial experience?

We started and then stumbled on for two-three years. Nothing moved because there were lots of communication problems. We had a lovely lady from Scotland and we had some people from Czech Republic… all trying to teach the kids the basics but it went over their heads. They were poles apart. And one day I was hearing them (The Sunshine Orchestra) and I was so frustrated that I felt like I failed completely. Then something told me that there’s something lacking here… there was lack of proper communication. I felt that a committed person should mentor and then I was looking at Srinivasa Murthy because when he takes up something he is always very very committed and loyal to that job. And then from then there was a miraculous change happened. I could see the kids smiling. He almost adopted them as his own children and you can see the difference now. He made them play in recordings and in concerts. They have now come to a level where they can play in Chennai. Now we want them to go to the international level.

Why did you name it Sunshine Orchestra?

I was toying with many names like Marina, and then I thought what is so common in Chennai. All four seasons (in Chennai) have sunshine (laughs). So even if rains come, it is there for two days or three days, it’s a rarity. So Chennai means sunshine. So why not Sunshine Orchestra, because this is from Chennai.

What’s your vision for the Sunshine Orchestra?

It is to develop and spread. So we have one in every metro in the country. There is the joy of hearing the music that the orchestra makes and then it creates jobs, which is one of the biggest challenges in our country. So why not make beautiful jobs like these.

These days musicians can collaborate across geographies, so is there really a need to have such orchestra?

You are talking about India and India has 1.3 billion people living in it. Why should we go to some other country? I actually want musicians from other countries to come and record here. Of course, there are certain things we should share with the world. We should share our knowledge with the world just as we shared yoga with the world. Similarly they share their knowledge with us. We shouldn’t be dependent on them. We should not have anything against anybody. But we should be independent.

And what do you think are the challenges going forward?

There will be a lot of financial challenges. You know for giving them more expert training. I am strengthening my foundation now and I think that will help a lot to meet the financial challenges. It’s the AR Rahman Foundation that helped me in making this a reality. But you can’t only think of money. You can’t think like that… money, money, money. Money goes.

- Jarshad NK


What AR Rahman did after pre-empting a talent shortage in the music industry is a case study for CEOs battling manpower crisis, reports Jarshad NK


Sometimes when her heart felt heavy, H Jayanthi would sit on the floor of her house and sing. Mostly, it would be about lost love and the pains of separation — one of the classics from Tamil film music of the 1950s and 60s. The 40-year-old had lost her husband nearly two decades ago when pregnant with her only child — H Jayamalini. Later, medical complications that required her to undergo a heart surgery forced her to quit working as a housemaid, straining the household budget further.


Not surprisingly though, music — which gives her solace — is also now giving her hope. Her daughter Jayamalini was handpicked to be part of an orchestra in Chennai, set up by two-time Academy Award winner AR Rahman. For the past six years, the 19-year-old has been training to play the violin for the orchestra. Jayamalini, who along with her mother lives with her uncle and grandmother, is also pursuing a degree in visual communications through correspondence. She has started performing publicly and is expected to turn professional in two years.


An idea is born

The Sunshine Orchestra, as it is called, is an ambitious project of the AR Rahman Foundation, the musician’s philanthropy initiative. The Orchestra hopes to address the Indian music industry’s urgent need to produce quality instrumentalists, who are in short supply. The Orchestra is also making a positive impact on society. Those who have been chosen to be part of the Sunshine Orchestra — and there are 34 so far — are from the underprivileged sections of society.


The idea for establishing such an orchestra came to Rahman towards the end of the last decade, when it dawned on him that most of the sessions players — the instrumentalists who play for movies — were in their 50s and 60s. There was no young talent being groomed. In a decade or so, he realised, there would be no quality instrumentalists. “Our sessions orchestra has really been amazing, but nobody wanted their sons or daughters to become musicians. They always felt that the next generation should not suffer like them by becoming musicians,” says Rahman.


The suffering that the composer refers to happened mostly in the 1980s, when the introduction of electronic music meant less work for instrumentalists. Computer-programmed music required only a handful of instrumentalists, down from over a hundred playing during song recordings earlier. The ground reality has changed since then (with composers blending instrumentalists with electronic music) and things are looking up for musicians. But there are fewer quality musicians. For instance, from about 300 to 400 top-notch violinists that Chennai boasted of till the 1980s, there are now only at best a couple of hundred. To set right the situation, many composers attempted to launch music schools. But nothing materialised.


“I had heard rumours about so many people starting a school but nothing really happened,” says Rahman. When the composer launched his KM Music Conservatory in 2008, he realised that most of the students were interested in learning piano or composition, or the voice courses. Not many wanted to do strings—short for stringed instruments such as violin and cello—which is the backbone of any orchestra. “Strings is very hard and needs a lot of commitment,” says Rahman. “Something told me that a kid from an upper middle-class family would do it for some time and then leave and do something else.” That is when the musician decided that he would teach it for free to those from the less privileged sections of society.


Rahman approached a school near his house in Chennai’s Dr Subbarayan Nagar — MGR Higher Secondary School — to find out if the management would be interested in getting its students trained in strings. It was. Initially, about 12 students were chosen, including Jayamalini, based on their aptitude for music. Most of them were either in the sixth or seventh standard. Though many of them had sung the odd prayer song during the morning assembly at school, none had heard any western classical music ever.


Jayamalini’s friend Vaijayanthi R, 17, who plays the cello for Sunshine, remembers the excitement of the first visit to Rahman’s studio near his house. “One day we got a call and our music teacher said let’s go to Rahman’s studio. We didn’t know it was for Sunshine Orchestra. We thought it was just for meeting Rahman and we were all excited,” says Vaijayanthi, who is now a part of the 12-member senior batch of Sunshine Orchestra that plays for films and live events.


Once they reached the studio, they were briefed on the idea and asked if they would like to be part of the orchestra. All of them agreed. Vaijayanthi said she chose to learn the cello because she “liked the shape of it,” though it was the first time she had set eyes on one. “Before that I knew nothing about music. No one in my family has learnt music or could play an instrument. I didn’t know who Bach was, Beethoven was. Illayaraja and Rahman were only musicians I had heard of.”


The initiative has found appreciation from other music composers, who are happy that something is being done to bring in fresh talent. “It’s a fantastic initiative. It will help composers like me a lot,” says Santhosh Narayanan, 32, one of the top music composers in the Tamil film industry. “Now I am forced to go abroad regularly to record with the orchestra there. More than the money, it will save people like me a lot of time and energy,” says the composer, who has worked in movies like Soodhu Kavvum,Jigarthanda and Cuckoo.


“There certainly is a talent vacuum and that will remain unless we as responsible musicians don’t encourage new talent,” says Mumbai-based composer Amit Trivedi. “I’m sure there is talent, those kids just need a medium. I’m in complete support of Rahman sir and his quest for talent,” adds Trivedi who has composed for movies such as Udaan and Queen.


The initial days

The classes for the first batch of Sunshine Orchestra began in 2009. The children would come at about seven in the morning to Rahman’s studio where they would be served breakfast before being taught the days lessons. From there they would go to school. Sometimes they would also have theory classes in the evening.


But after almost four years of classes when Rahman dropped in one day to take stock of their progress he was deeply disappointed. The kids had not learnt much. “I was so frustrated that I felt like I failed completely,” says Rahman. “Then something told me that there’s something lacking here. There was no proper communication.”


Most of the teachers taking classes so far had been foreigners. Though excellent coaches, they couldn’t cross the language and cultural barriers between them and the Sunshine students. That was when Rahman decided that he must bring in Srinivasa Murthy, 63, a violinist-turned-music conductor who has been working with the four-time national award winner since 1991.


“We had finished a recording as usual and I was about to go home when Rahman said he wanted to speak to me. He sounded very down,” recalls Murthy, who began learning the violin at the age of four. “Even after four years nothing has been done. He told me that we have actually wasted the time of those kids. The way he told me it was very touching, so I said ‘okay I will have a look at it’. Next morning I went in to give it a try.”


Murthy now teaches strings for the senior batch of 11 at the KM College of Music and Technology, while the lone flautist is taught by another teacher in the same premises. The junior batches are taught in classrooms in Rahman’s studio by other teachers.


Progress, at last

Since Murthy took over the progress has been rapid. Sunshine Orchestra has played for events and for a few films, including Tamil superstar Rajinikanth’s Lingaa. “It took five-six months for me to get close to them. I liked the children, and then they started liking me,” says Murthy, who is now also training them in Indian classical music. “Music cannot be taught by taking an hour’s class a day or through two classes a week. It has to be full time.” After passing their twelfth board exams, the Sunshine children are being taught music full time. Those who want to do higher studies opt to do so through a correspondence course.


And it’s not because the children are poor in academics. One of them, M Balaji, who plays the cello, got full marks in three subjects in his tenth standard board examinations, scoring 491 marks out of a possible 500. But he is clear that his future is in music. “Why should everyone become a doctor or an engineer? How many will get an opportunity like this? He is interested in music, so let him learn music,” says D Manoharan, Balaji’s father, who earns a living by ironing clothes.


Murthy says that in another couple of years the senior batch of Sunshine Orchestra would be good enough to play for others. He is confident that their talent would earn them decent incomes. Currently, a sessions player gets about ₹2,500 every day. Most of them get work for about 15-20 days a month if they are good. The top class ones earn as much as ₹10,000-15,000 a day when they play solo. Studying music at AR Rahman’s school also raised the standing of the children among relatives and neighbours. Their musical instruments occupy the pride of place in their homes and their parents would invariable ask them to play a tune or two when guests dropped in.


“I haven’t stepped into a studio ever. I got to see such instruments only because my daughter is learning music from AR Rahman’s school. So naturally, it’s a great source of pride for us,” says S Vijaya, 43, mother of S Deepa who is one of the three cello players of Sunshine Orchestra. Besides the instruments, all members of the senior batch have been given a smartphone and a laptop by the AR Rahman Foundation.


The challenges ahead

One key challenge would be to retain the talent. As it is a long-term project (10-15 years), some of the members could opt out. For instance, one girl from the first batch dropped out after getting into a regular college and couldn’t keep up with the music training. But the biggest challenge could be the funding, especially as Rahman wants to replicate it in other metros of the country.


Also, instruments are expensive. When the brass section was set up a couple of months ago, the instruments alone cost about ₹85 lakh. Also, a teacher at the conservatory would be paid ₹12-14 lakh a year besides food and lodging. And then there is the added expense if the children have to be trained abroad. But like Rahman says, it’s not all about the money. “You can’t think like that… money, money money. Money goes,” he says.




(This article was published on May 11, 2015)


S Deepa, cello


Anish Franklin, contra bass



A Nandhini, violin



A Balaji, violin



Manoj R, contra bass



Sunshine Orchestra
















Wednesday, 6 May 2015

Crash into Eurasia: India moved at 5.9 inches/yr, say geologists


Crash into Eurasia: India moved at 5.9 inches/yr, say geologists

  • HT Correspondent, Hindustan Times, Mumbai
  • | 
  • Updated: May 05, 2015 22:38 IST
Relics and rocks found in the Himalayas have resolved a long standing puzzle on India’s record speed when it crashed into Eurasia 80 million years ago, revealed geologists from the Massachusetts Institute of Technology (MIT).
India, after breaking away from supercontinent Gondwana – which also comprised present day Madagascar, Arabia, Africa and South America – started drifting at a remarkable speed around 120 million years ago. Moving at a speed of 40mm or 1.57 inches per year about 80 million years ago, India suddenly accelerated to 150mm or 5.9 inches per year and continued at the same pace for 30 million years till it collided with Eurasia and gave rise to the Himalayas.
According to the study published in Nature Geoscience, a combination of two subduction zones was responsible for the speed at which India kept moving northwards after splitting from Gondwana in the southern hemisphere. Double subduction zones refer to the Earth's mantle where the edge of one tectonic plate sinks under another plate, and pulls along any connected landmasses owing to twice the pulling power.
“In earth science, it's hard to be completely sure of anything," said Leigh Royden, professor of geology and geophysics in MIT's Department of Earth, Atmospheric and Planetary Sciences in a release. “But there are so many pieces of evidence that all fit together here that we're pretty convinced.”
Having found relics of what may have been two subduction zones and dating rocks from the Himalayan region, the MIT team developed a computer simulated model for a double subduction system and incorporated the measurements they obtained from the Himalayas into their model.
According to the study, the speed India’s landmass drifted was likely to have depended on the width of the subducting plates, and the distance between them. If the plates are relatively narrow and far apart, they would likely cause India to drift at a faster rate.
“When you look at simulations of Gondwana breaking up, India comes slowly off of Antarctica, and suddenly it just zooms across,” said Royden.
http://www.hindustantimes.com/india-news/crash-into-eurasia-india-moved-at-5-9-inches-yr-say-geologists/article1-1344269.aspx

Tuesday, 5 May 2015

Shashaa Tirupati on ARR


AR Rahman sir is my saviour: O Kadhal Kanmani singer Shashaa Tirupati

  • Vignesh Radhakrishnan, Hindustan Times, New Delhi
  • | 
  • Updated: May 05, 2015 15:47 IST

O Kadhal Kanmani singer Shashaa Tirupati. (Photo : Facebook profile)


She was born in Srinagar, raised in Vancouver, got her training in music from Allahabad and Benaras, been a Mumbai resident for close to five years now, sings in Marathi, Bengali, Punjabi, Tamil, Telugu, Kannada, Hindi and English, and has a sweet spot for middle eastern and Sufi forms of music. While 27-year-old Shashaa Tirupati was busy in her own whirlwind life, things took an unthinkable turn two years ago : She was spotted by the Mozart of Madras A R Rahman!

And like it always happens with all Rahman discoveries, Shashaa's the newest sensation of the music world: Her voice is running in loops across India, with the three soul-searching songs she sang in Mani Ratnam's latest Tamil romcom O Kadhal Kammani.
http://www.hindustantimes.com/Images/popup/2015/5/shasha1.jpg
Shashaa Tirupati. (Photo: Facebook)
Shashaa's is yet another example of Rahman's keen eye for spotting talent: He's hailed as a music scientist who experiments with voices for no other reason. Before his entry into Tamil films, the South Indian music industry was suffering from the 'one-film-one-singer' syndrome. A cursory glance of any well-known music directors' discography will show that they rotated a set of accomplished singers for all their songs. New singers were hard to come by, and variety was only in genres, never in the voices.
It was only after the Oscar winner's entry into film music in Mani Ratnam's Roja that many unknown singers started getting their big-breaks. In his debut film, he used a rookie singer called Minmini (though credit has to go to Ilayaraaja for introducing her first) to sing Chinna Chinna Asai (in Hindi Chhoti Si Asha), which catapulted her to international fame.   
The trend continued in many other Mani Ratnam-AR Rahman combinations. Sadhana Sargam became a household name after she sang Snegithane Snegithane (in Hindi Chupke se) from the Tamil film Alaipayuthey (remade in Hindi as Saathiya) and an unknown singer Shakti Shree Gopalan became a hot search topic after ARR made her sing Nenjukulle song from Mani Ratnam's Kadal.
And now we have Shashaa! While she is revelling in her new-found star status, the singer bares her heart on a range of issues in an email interview with Hindustan Times, from her Tamil pronunciations, getting 'spotted' by A R Rahman, and her future plans.

http://www.hindustantimes.com/Images/popup/2015/5/shasha2.jpg
Shashaa Tirupati. (Photo: Facebook)
Your Tamil pronunciation is perfect. How did you manage this without knowing the language?

I have always had a strange love for languages. I taught myself Punjabi, Bengali, Farsi, Italian, Urdu and a few other languages. When it comes to Tamil, though I understand it a bit, I think having listened to almost every Rahman sir's album has helped me improve my stylisation and diction. The rest of it is purely guidance from ARR sir and his team.
In general, is it necessary for you to understand the meaning of the songs you sing? 
Of course you need to know what you’re singing! Music is nothing but an expression of emotion. Understanding the significance of the words and phrases is key to creating an impact at the right moments in a song. The soul of a song comes intrinsically. I don’t want to be a technical singer. I want to be a technically sound singer who makes hearts tingle.
You call ARR your inspiration. How was it working with him?

Inspiration seems too small a word in front of the influence he has had in my life. He is all what I am today. He believed in a voice that so many others rejected. He utilised my voice at a time no one else felt I had it in me. He’s been a saviour.

http://www.hindustantimes.com/Images/popup/2015/5/shashaa3.jpg
Shashaa Tirupati. (Photo: Facebook)
When and how did ARR notice you?
This one always makes my stomach flutter! It was for Coke Studio Season 3 in 2013. I owe all my experiences and opportunities with ARR sir to a dear friend and co-worker, Nitish, also a mixing engineer on sir’s team. He told me about the auditions for a Hindustani Choir sir wished to put together for his episode that season. I auditioned with six others, and by God’s Grace, was selected. During one of the rehearsals, ARR sir randomly asked which one of us was Shashaa and I hesitantly raised my pinky. I thought I had messed up and was singing the harmonies all wrong. Next day I mustered the courage and asked him if I had done something wrong. He said my voice sounded like a musical instrument. I was relieved, but even more confused now, wondering if that was a compliment or a strike out!
A month after our episode was telecast, I received a call from his studio and was asked if I could fly down to Chennai the next day as sir wanted to try my voice…  That was the point I realised it was a good thing to sound like a musical instrument! That song was Vaada Vaada from Kochadaiiyaan.
What were his first words to you and yours to him? Any memorable exchanges with him that you cherish? 

First words: “Which one of you is Shashaa?”

The most memorable and grateful moment I’ll owe to him would be that first trip for his work to Chennai. I fell ill with a horrible throat and cough and was unable to record. The world ended for me, considering this was the moment I had prayed for all my life. I met sir and he calmly told me that as soon as I feel better, I could let him know, as he has kept the song aside for me. He could have replaced me with one of those million singers dying to work with him, but he didn't. Hence my immeasurable dedication towards Him.
If you are asked to list 3 ARR songs which you wish you had sung which three would you choose?
Three? How about three hundred! Seriously speaking, it would be insulting to even think of being in place of any of the veteran singers. I’d rather say a few of ARR sir’s songs that are extremely close to my heart with female lines -- Kehna Hi Kya, Tu Hi Re, Tere Bina Besuadi and Jiya Jale. What Chitra ma, Lata ji, and Kavitha ji have done is beyond divine.
You've sung 5 songs for ARR till now. Which one of these are you most satisfied with?
Well, with film releases including Telugu versions/languages, the total number is not 5 but about 9. Every song I've sung for sir so far has its very own set of experiences, lessons, and vibe. As serene as Vaada Vaada was, Aye Mr. Minor had its own element of chirpiness, Naane Varugiren its thrill and challenge and Parandhu Sella Vaa had scope for experimentation and playfulness midst western and Hindustani classical.

Let's now talk about your songs in Ok Kanmani. Among the three you've sung for the film, which one was the most difficult and why? 
Each song had its challenges, but Naane Varugiraen was a different thing altogether. I never thought I’d be able to do justice to such intricate brilliance! It was a tug of war between taal and sur and expression. Concentrating on one would lead to losing out on the other. It took me a good 3-4 hours to dub this song, and sir has been the epitome of patience and faith dealing with me on this one!
Did you make any impromptu improvisations in any of these three songs which ARR liked and included?
He’s the king of improvs! He kept shooting out what was going on in his mind, especially in Parandhu Sella Vaa, and yet he would encourage us (Karthik and myself) to come up with little phrases. So little things like the classical parts that I did were beautifully retained and placed whereas all the funky “takachikatakachikas”, “tikadhum tikadhum”s were sir’s craft.
Any particular experience you would like to recount which you cherished during Ok Kanmani recordings?

Seeing AR sir and Mani (Ratnam) sir in the same room. Greatness Overload. Till then I didn't know I was singing for the their film! I had haunting themes and scenes of Guru, Bombay, Roja playing in my head while I watched them both work.
Was there any particular stanza in these three songs which took you a lot of takes before rendering it perfectly? Any hardest bit?

From the first line till the last line of "Naane Varugiraen". It’ll be a sure shot task performing that live !
So what's on your plate next? Are you doing more Tamil songs or going back to Hindi?

As much as I've been working towards Bollywood playback, I adore Tamil music and cinema. Hence, I regularly travel between both cities as and when I’m required for recordings. I’m working with several composers down south as well as in Mumbai.
You are a Canadian with roots in Kashmir?
I've been a multicultural and multinational kid! I was born in Srinagar, raised in Vancouver, had music training in Allahabad and Benares, and I've been living in Mumbai for about four and a half years now. I've sung in Marathi, Bengali, Punjabi, Tamil, Telugu, Kannada, Hindi, and English and have a sweet spot for middle eastern and sufi forms of music.
I spent most of my childhood in Canada, where I grew up singing, performing, swimming, practicing seikeido, ice skating, girl scouting, playing soccer, and reading! Then my parents brought me to India to seek classical training. I was oscillating between Vancouver and Allahabad in the midst of that.
http://www.hindustantimes.com/Images/popup/2015/5/shashaa4.jpg
Shashaa Tirupati. (Photo: Facebook)
I went back post my junior college for higher studies in Canada, had topped the province in my grad school and went on to university on a full scholarship, besides 6 other scholarships. But then I dropped out of pre-med after hearing ARR sir's “Dum dara dum dara mast mast” song in the film "Guru" and decided this is what I want to do for the rest of my life. I wanted to be prepared to sing under ARR Sir. I kept him in my mandir for 12 years and felt that impressing him wouldn't be easy.
I practiced for two years and then kind of ran away from home. I came to Bombay, did some reality shows and hundreds of jingles for the funding and shows and some 15 odd Hindi and various regional films' playback, but I maintained the riyaaz as the bigger picture was something else. Finally through Coke Studio I realised my dream.
Anything else you want to mention?
I would like to thank the team at Panchathan- Suresh Permal, Srinivasa Murthy, Srinivasa Doraiswamy, Srinidhi Venkatesh, Jerry Silvester Vincent, Sami Durai, Nitish R, PA Deepak, Karthik, Chetan, Vijay, Ishaan - all these people were crucial parts of the entire process and making us sound as beautiful as we did in the final product.

http://www.hindustantimes.com/regional/ar-rahman-sir-is-my-saviour-o-kadhal-kanmani-singer-shashaa-tirupati/article1-1344107.aspx

Shiva Ayyadurai on inventing email and the backlash that followed

http://yourstory.com/2015/02/shiva-ayyadurai/

‘This curry stained Indian should be beaten and hanged': Shiva Ayyadurai on inventing email and the backlash that followed


I first heard of Shiva Ayyadurai while randomly scrolling through Facebook. A news article from Huffington Post appeared on my newsfeed, mentioning Shiva Ayyadurai as the inventor of email and honouring him for his achievements on the thirtieth anniversary of email. A quick google search produced another interesting piece, again from Huffington Post, which stated how two big American corporations-Raytheon and BBN- ran a sustained PR campaign to discredit and malign the brown teenager from Newark, New Jersey who was the true inventor of email.
yourstory_VA_Shiva_Ayyadurai_InsideArticle
In postcolonial India where we are quick to claim and glorify the slightest recognition from the West, I was baffled at how I had not come across his name before; especially given the magnitude of this achievement. For Ayyadurai allegedly invented email when he was only fourteen. The rest of his life is glittery with a vast array of entrepreneurial achievements (uncontested ones) from earning four degrees at MIT to founding Echo Mail,revamping the US Postal system and many more.
I saved both the articles to Pocket and forgot about them for a few days. When I tried to read them later, they weren’t to be found. An exhaustive search around the internet later I learnt that all the pieces hailing Ayyadurai as the inventor of email were taken down after a flurry of readers protested this to be categorically false. That honour instead went to American inventor Ray Tomlinson. Any search for Shiva Ayyadurai yielded three kinds of results:his recent marriage to Hollywood actress Fran Drescher, torrents of racial and other abuse deeming him to be a liar and a fraud and Ayyadurai’s own slew of registered domains.
It was difficult to gauge the authenticity of his claims from either the trolls or his own websites. Confused, I reached out to him for an interview and he obliged. But a lengthy conversation later, my confusion has not abated much. Rather than endorsing or criticizing his claims (which this author anyway has no authority to do), this interview is an attempt at opening up legitimate avenues of conversation where we can discuss, critique and opine coherently and with dignity- something the American media has largely failed to do and our Indian brethren have not expressed much interest in either. He says, “The main contention against me is that I am a self-promotional businessman. I am an internet entrepreneur. What does that have to do with the material facts of who invented email?”
We welcome your thoughts in the comments below. Please note that here we discuss only the contentious email issue. A more comprehensive conversation on his life, education and other achievements is forthcoming next week.
You were close to dropping out of school when your mother introduced you to Les Michelson (scientist at University of Medicine and Dentistry of New Jersey, under whose tutelage Shiva says he invented the email.)
Yes. I was fourteen years old at the time.
What was going on your mind when you were fourteen? 
In India I came from a family of farmers. My grandmother was a farmer. My mother, despite coming from an ‘untouchable’ lower caste family, worked impossibly hard to educate herself. My father grew up in the war and did not learn to read or write till he turned eleven. When we moved to the United States in 1970 at the age of seven I was keen to do well. Every time I went to India I realized how fortunate I was to have been given the opportunities I had, especially given where I came from. I knew I was not doing well for me but for so many who had sacrificed so I could be here. From then on I was motivated to change the world.
How did the idea for creating the email come about?
Imagine the world in 1978. No PC’s, no smartphones and no laptops. The ordinary person did not have access to the computer. Those who got to use it were highly technical people- system analysts, programmers, etc. and they too used it only for data processing.
For me email was not a technical person sending another technical person a message. It was the entire system and it was designed for the ordinary end user. A doctor, a dentist or a secretary. So they would move from a typewriter to the computer terminal. That was what made email revolutionary.
Before Steve Jobs created the computer, people had to build their own computers. They had to buy the parts separately and assemble it. That’s what made the Mackintosh revolutionary. It was accessible to millions of people. Email made the computer accessible to millions of people and that’s what I invented.
How did you come upon the idea?
The idea was to make communication accessible for the ordinary end user. It was not just making text messaging accessible. That’s what they were doing. We had about a hundred different features. You see a secretary would not move to email unless it had all the features she was used to. She was used to seeing an inbox, outbox, address book and a trash folder. She was used to getting a return receipt. All these features needed to be interconnected. Email is a system of interconnected parts. It was like creating an engine.
One of the most common criticisms levelled against you is that you don’t acknowledge that your invention was built on the works of those who came before you in the sixties, especially individuals like Ray Tomlinson and organizations like ARPANET. How much of inventing the Email was original and what was based on prior works?
You have to understand the politics at work here. Over here is the military, the private industry and academia. What they were doing in the sixties and the seventies was trying to send a message from Point A to Point B for soldiers in the battle field. In 1978, at the age of fourteen, I had no access to that technology, did not use any of their parts. And this is what needs to be brought out. We didn’t need any of their stuff to bring out the Email. We didn’t even need the internet.
The early email systems, from the one I built to all the way up to 1993 and you can read up on the facts yourself, did not use the internet. They were built around local area networks. In one office we literally ran ether net cords and set up our computers. We were not using their networks and protocols at all.
They want the world to think that you need the military. That the military industrial complex creates great technologies. The reason there is so much anger and backlash is because we, as a public, have been taught to believe that our tax dollars fund the defence department. The defence department does research and once in a while we get GPS. We get Velcro. We get email. It’s a way of justifying all this spending on the military.
In 1978 I did not use even a single of their components. I didn’t need it.
Philo Farnsworth, a fourteen year old boy from a small town in Idaho, invented the television. They attacked him just as viciously. We are changing the narrative here. What we are saying is that a small kid from India or Idaho could invent life changing things. We don’t have to spend billions funding the military. The military industrial complex has convinced us that we should fund them because they are the big innovators. Only a white man could create something like that. A dark skinned kid in Newark, New Jersey-the thought of him creating the email is like an explosion to these people. That’s why they have to pull down articles. You go my Wikipedia page and run through the list of previously published articles discussing my works and achievements. All the links have been destroyed. I have been a scientist and an inventor for forty years of my life. The idea is to not only destroy the accurate account of events but also to destroy me.
The reason is not about me. It is about preserving that military industrial complex where we go kill people in the Middle East and bomb people and because of them great innovations come. It’s not true. The email was invented through collaboration. But it was not of the military but through the collaboration of good teachers, my parents, Michaelson and the support of a small local environment. And that is revolutionary. If people know that the email and television were created by fourteen year old kids, then they realize they don’t need to spend enormous sums backing the military. And that’s what they are afraid of.
Huffington Post ran an article about myths surrounding the invention of email that has since been taken down. For purposes of posterity, can you give a rundown of some of those myths?
The first myth was that the ARPANET created email. Absolutely false. What they did was electronic text messaging. The ARPANET was working on battlefield communications via telegraph. It was a very rudimentary system. David Crocker himself, in December 1977, wrote an article saying, “No attempt is being made to emulate a full-scale, inter-organizational mail system.”
The second myth was that Ray Tomlinson invented email and that he sent the first email message. Ray Tomlinson did not write fifty thousand lines of code. He wrote may be fifteen twenty lines of code. He took an old program, manipulated it a little bit and he used the ‘@’ symbol to designate two computers. That’s not email. That’s not inbox outbox folders. But BBN and Raytheon launched a massive PR campaign to discredit my work. They wanted to build their brand. Being known as the inventors of email would give them tremendous advantage towards winning billions of dollars of security contract.
The frankly racist articles put up at Gizmodo and Techdirt claim that RFCs were emails. RFC’s are meeting notes. It meant Request for Comment. In those days you had a meeting, a bunch of guys were at the table and they would write out the meeting notes. They would send the meeting notes to everyone involved. RFCs are not a computer program. They are not any type of a specification for user interface.
It’s also claimed that the CTSS was email. CTSS was the system that was developed at MIT and it was essentially an early blog or wall post at best. They called it mail because in those days they would have a file and you could tack on another post to it. That’s not email. Email by definition (I am the one who defined it, I am the one who came up with the word and I am the one who created it) is a system of interlocking parts- inbox, outbox, folders and all those things.
It was in 2012, after Washington Post carried an article about your work being honoured by the Smithsonian, that the avalanche of backlash begun and peaked. Can you elaborate on that?
Everyone attacks India to be the most corrupt country in the world. But it has nothing on American corruption. Here it is deep, entrenched and done in a very sophisticated manner.
The article in Washington Post was written by a young black reporter. She started getting trolled within an hour of the piece being published. She called me up and said that my editor has thrown me under the bus and asked me to write a rebuttal against two people who were leading the backlash against me- one was a historian in the pocket of Raytheon. I chose to co-write my rebuttal with Noam Chomsky.
yourstory_VA_Shiva_Ayyadurai
When they finally ran the article, they only went with David Crocker. Even then, they didn’t deny that I invented email. They said that electronic messaging existed before I came along. I am not saying I invented electronic messaging. Its existence goes back to the time of Morse code. But I did create email.
Within seven days of the Washington Post article going live, they created an internet hall of fame and gave an award to Ray Tomlinson for creating the email. This is how the system works.
Raytheon’s stock went up by $1 immediately after this announcement. There was a renewed flurry of hate campaigning against me. One blog said, “This curry stained Indian should be beaten and hanged.” If an Indian does great software coding, outsourcing or is the chairman of Microsoft, then that’s cool. But an Indian cannot be an innovator. I am labelled a fraud. Wikipedia calls me a scoundrel, a conman and a liar.
When you patented EMAIL in 1982, there was little distinction between a copyright and a patent. When it collapsed 14 years later, in 1996, why didn’t you renew it?
1980 was when the copyright act was converted to support software rights. In 1981 I was sixteen and not aware of the complexities and politics at play. I couldn’t afford a lawyer and so did all the paperwork on my own. It was only in the early 1990’s that the Supreme Court began recognizing software patents. I couldn’t file for my patent then because you can’t patent something that’s already been disclosed.
Do you grudge being denied prospective profits as a consequence of this patent issue not working out?
Walter Issacson’s new book ‘Innovators’, a book featuring solely white inventors, says that true innovation happens when the government, military and academia work together. Issacson says that the biggest motive for innovation is profit. The concept of money being the sole motive for innovation is bullshit. It is an idea promoted by those in power in order to manipulate humanity.
Today my fight is no longer about who invented email. The facts are in black and white and your readers are free to make an informed choice. I am more concerned with who controls innovation and how is humanity going to move forward.


[This interview has been edited and condensed]